Stubborn Analyst looking for Available Keywords…

I used to work for online dating services, website project management and website performance analysis and always had a lot of fun reading the ads most of the time not very interesting but sometimes funny, wacky or truly desperate – honestly, best lunch break ever ! Don’t get me wrong, it’s really difficult to describe in a few sentences what you could want in a person and who you truly are without sounding a tiny bit desperate. Well, no shame on my side :

keywords-classified-adIn reaction to Google encrypting natural and now paid search queries in mass ; I know that Google do not care a minute of my POV but anyhow as in love I will not hold back my feelings anymore: angry and desperate ! Or am I just blind maybe, a lot says that it’s not a big deal that now 70-80% of the keywords are displayed “Not Available”… I mean, really ? I know it’s not the end of the world: keyword performance analysis is not dead – Third party PPC management platforms & Google Adwords are not affected but my point of view here is only analytics platform focus. I love new challenges and evolution is key. But I kind of like having all my stuff in one place, sure I don’t mind bringing some external fun from time to time in my routine but most of the time it’s easier to have everything in 1 place and I rather spend time analyzing than doing data enablement, but that’s just me. My place being my analytics reports/dashboard Omniture or GA and external fun being Google Adwords & Google Webmaster Tool, and it’s getting more difficult to analyze without making too much assumptions.

What happened and What does it mean?

keyowrds-strip-weboptimeez

Let’s focus on the last announcement, being a little bit stubborn, I checked – double checked – cross checked and ask around ; here are some quotes from my findings:

Today, we are extending our efforts to keep search secure by removing the query from the referer on ad clicks originating from SSL searches on Google.com.

Google Ads Developer Blog

“What has actually happened is that Google team has announced that they are removing the query from the referrer on ad clicks by users who use secure (SSL) search on Google.com. So analytics packages et. al. won’t have access to this data.”

Avinash Kaushik

The gist of the development is that when people using secure search click on AdWords ads, the user’s search query in the referrer string — the actual words that people entered into the search box — won’t be passed to analytics packages and third-party software.

Searchengineland.com

They’re going to be stripping the paid search keyword from the URL, which is how adobe/google analytics collects the data. You can access paid keywords in adwords or via their API. it will not be available in google analytics or adobe analytics.

Adobe Marketing Care

Well, I think it’s clear – Analytics vendors will not anymore have access to keywords the way they used to ‘via the referrer string’. But let’s be very clear, it doesn’t mean that natural search or paid search won’t be identified as what they are – it means that keyword level analysis from an analytics perspective won’t be easy. When before you looked at your branded keywords, top keywords, long tail keywords… against your bounce rate, engagement & conversion rates ; well.. you just have to stop doing that.

What can we do about it?

When last year, the Natural searches were hit – well as everyone, I made myself a reason and found alternatives:

  1. Looking at landing page report and deducting from there; knowing that most of the time your landing pages are optimized for a specific list of keywords – we could in a way extrapolate from this using either custom variables or classifications to tag each of your page in a set of topics.
  2. Looking at Google Webmaster Tools; knowing that Google Webmaster tools reports displays the volume of clicks and impressions by query. Unfortunately this is limited as you can’t drilldown this report with your site objectives and KPI only again geographic data and you can’t segment either.
  3. Looking at paid search keywords reports, as there is a well know synergy between paid and organic searches
  4. Looking at site search reports; it can be very useful especially for ecommerce websites where the audience is more likely to use your internal search function. Also from there you match and extrapolate
  5. Looking at the VED parameter to get more insight about the type of results your audience clicked on, you’ll capture information such as type of :image, blog, sitelink, placement…

In summary for natural search, no changes here – stick to your routine except #3. And appreciate that this change brought a change of perspective shifting towards more user behavioral, user segmentation/personae focus instead of keywords only. Still, i don’t think it hurts to have both.

As for paid search, what should we do now?

Well, I would suggest that we go on strike ! but being realistic I believe we just need to adapt as indeed it’s not the end of the world – search vendors as still working perfectly – you can have your data from Google Adwords or your third party PPC management platforms, but i had to complain first ! Aside from the list above which is applicable for paid search as well (#2 use Adwords instead of Google Webmaster tool in this case) ; Google advise as well that for generating reports or automating keyword management with query data, use the AdWords API Search Query Performance report or the AdWords Scripts Report service and alternatively use ValueTrack parameters.

ValueTrack parameters in a few words ; this feature allows to dynamically populate the keyword into the destination URL; the keywords not the query the users typed but if you include also the match type parameter (broad, exact…) you will have a close idea of the query.
valuetrack-parameters
In this example above, the parameter capture is the device type, but any other parameter can be appended. See below exhaustive list and click ont he image to be redirected to the methodology.
Capture d’écran 2014-05-06 à 23.30.11
What about you? How do you intend to deal with “Not Provided” growth?

Hope you enjoy the reading, please share if you did !

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title="" rel=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>